For this year’s Advent Organ Recital at First Pres, I will be performing a monumental work for the pipe organ: Max Reger’s Phantasie über den Choral "Wie schön leuchtet uns der Morgenstern," Op. 40, No. 1. It is a demanding, towering piece of music—one that carries deep significance in Reger’s life, rich Advent symbolism, and a special place in my own relationship with the instrument.
Johann Baptist Joseph Maximilian Reger (1873–1916) was a late German Romantic composer who was frequently—and fiercely—criticized during his lifetime for his uncompromising style. His music is densely chromatic and relentless, offering listeners very few breaks from its emotional and harmonic intensity. In many ways, his pushing of tonal boundaries served as a direct bridge to Arnold Schoenberg’s twelve-tone system and the rise of atonality.
Reger also thought on a massive scale. He wrote hundreds of works over the course of his life including works for orchestra, chamber music, organ, solo works for various instruments, lieder, and concertos. His sinfonietta (meaning “little symphony”) lasts nearly fifty minutes! He also would give over a hundred concerts each year as he worked for the Royal Academy of Music in Munich teaching counterpoint and composition. And his Choral Fantasies routinely stretch from twelve to twenty minutes putting them into the category of large scale organ works. Because it is nearly impossible to fit a twenty-minute solo into a standard church liturgy, Reger conceived these choral fantasies primarily for the concert hall, treating the organ as a true symphonic powerhouse.
To truly understand Reger, it helps to picture him standing with one foot in the progressive, late-Romantic future and the other firmly planted in the Baroque past. Reger began his formal musical studies with organ lessons at age eleven, and Johann Sebastian Bach quickly became his musical North Star.
Rather than abandoning traditional forms in pursuit of modern harmony, Reger saw himself as a direct continuation of Bach’s lineage—taking the older master’s dense, intricate counterpoint, fugues, and other forms and clothing them in the lush, chromatic language of late-nineteenth-century Germany. You can hear this reverence immediately in his very first Choral Fantasy, based on "Ein feste Burg ist unser Gott" ("A Mighty Fortress Is Our God"), which opens with a thunderous pedal
solo on the organ—a bold, dramatic gesture ripped straight from the playbook of Bach’s great organ works.
In channeling Bach, Reger was also staking his own claim in music history. Throughout the nineteenth century, Germany was in the midst of a massive "Bach Revival," sparked largely by Felix Mendelssohn’s famous 1829 performance of the St. Matthew Passion. During his own lifetime, Bach was viewed mostly as a local church musician and an old-fashioned contrapuntist; it took generations for the world to recognize his genius. By consciously anchoring his modern compositions in Bach’s timeless forms, Reger was connecting himself to a musical tradition that had already proven it could endure for centuries—and continues to captivate audiences today.
One of the most fascinating quirks of Reger’s career is his devotion to the Lutheran chorale. Raised in a devout Catholic family, Reger remained a practicing Catholic his entire life, yet he poured his energy into writing massive masterpieces based on Protestant hymns. When asked about this apparent contradiction, Reger leaned into the irony with his trademark cheeky wit. He quipped that Protestants of his era no longer seemed to appreciate the profound beauty and majesty of their own musical heritage—so if they weren't going to step up and do it justice, a Catholic would have to do it for them.
To make sense of Reger’s complex web of sound, it helps to listen for a centuries-old compositional technique called the cantus firmus ("fixed song"). In this style, a familiar hymn melody is played plainly in one voice while intricate, swirling musical lines weave around it. The cantus firmus acts as a steady anchor in the storm. Reger even printed the stanzas of the hymn text directly into his organ score so the performer could shape the music to match the poetry.
The hymn at the center of this piece—"Wie schön leuchtet uns der Morgenstern" ("How Brightly Shines the Morning Star")—is royalty in music history. This choral sits comfortably as the theme for Bach’s Cantata catalogued as BWV 1 (the first work catalogued from all of Bach’s compositions), and Felix Mendelssohn featured it prominently in his unfinished oratorio Christus, written in the final year of his life.
For Advent, the text is a joyful celebration of Christ as the Light of the World, evoking the Star of Bethlehem guiding us toward the Nativity. Reger explores every facet of this hymn, moving from moments of quiet, radiant simplicity to
breathtaking virtuosity. He caps the piece with a massive fugue, bringing the chorale theme back at the very end as a triumphant, full-organ declaration of the hymn tune.
Reger’s music also cannot be separated from the instruments he wrote it for: the grand German symphonic organs of the late nineteenth century, built by masters like Wilhelm Sauer and Eberhard Friedrich Walcker.
Unlike the bright, transparent Baroque organs of Bach’s day, these instruments were packed with lush foundation stops designed to produce a seamless, towering wall of sound. To help organists manage these tonal resources, Sauer and Walcker pioneered technologies that are still standard on modern pipe organs today, including:
For me, this music is deeply personal. One of the major milestones of my time studying at the Eastman School of Music was learning Reger’s Choral Fantasy on "Ein feste Burg." As a lifelong devotee of Bach, I found Reger’s compositional world completely irresistible—it gave me the intricate, contrapuntal rigor of Bach wrapped in the thrilling, massive sonic power of a late-Romantic symphony orchestra.
I still remember how the unexpected turns of his counterpoint, anchored by that unshakeable hymn melody, could move me to tears. Exploring "Wie schön leuchtet uns der Morgenstern" for this recital has brought back that exact same rush of emotion. It is a rare privilege to share music that is at once so niche, so demanding, and so spiritually rich—and I am honored to bring this monumental piece to life for you at First Pres.